- 643 Insurance Insight
- Posts
- Not At-Fault And Comprehensive Claims
Not At-Fault And Comprehensive Claims
Why These Claims Impact Your Auto Insurance Premiums
At 643 Insurance, we understand how frustrating it can be when your auto insurance premium increases after a claim, especially when the accident wasn’t your fault or the claim seems minor. Many policyholders wonder, “Why would a not-at-fault accident, a roadside assistance claim, or even a windshield replacement affect my premium?” Let’s unpack the reasons behind these premium adjustments to give you a clearer picture.

Not-At-Fault Accidents: An Industry-Wide Trend
While a not-at-fault accident may seem like something that shouldn’t affect your premium, it can still have an impact. Here’s why:
Increased Risk Perception: Insurance companies use extensive data to assess risk, and statistics show that drivers involved in not-at-fault accidents are slightly more likely to be involved in future accidents. While you may be a cautious driver, the increased likelihood of future claims could prompt a premium adjustment.
Claims History: Even if the accident wasn’t your fault, it still goes on your insurance record. This record is used to calculate your overall risk profile, and any accident-regardless of fault- can contribute to a higher risk assessment.
Roadside Assistance Claims: Seemingly Minor, Yet Meaningful
Roadside assistance claims, such as towing or jumpstarts, are often considered minor. However, these claims can still lead to premium increases for several reasons:
Frequency of Claims: Insurance companies may view frequent roadside assistance claims as an indicator of underlying risk, such as an aging vehicle or lack of proper maintenance, which could lead to larger claims in the future.
Claim Costs Add Up: While each individual claim might seem small, the cumulative cost of roadside assistance claims can affect overall premiums, especially if they’re frequent over a short period.
Windshield Replacement and Comprehensive Claims
Comprehensive claims, such as windshield replacements, are common and often seem straightforward. Yet, these claims can also impact premiums:
Frequency of Claims: Insurance companies may view frequent roadside assistance claims as an indicator of underlying risk, such as an aging vehicle or lack of proper maintenance, which could lead to larger claims in the future.
Claim Costs Add Up: While each individual claim might seem small, the cumulative cost of roadside assistance claims can affect overall premiums, especially if they’re frequent over a short period.

Why Do Insurance Companies Adjust Premiums?
It’s important to remember that insurance is a business based on risk assessment. Each claim, whether it’s large or small, contributes to your overall risk profile. Additionally, insurers must ensure they have enough revenue to cover claims for all policyholders, which is why claims history plays such a significant role in premium calculations.
While some factors are beyond your control, there are steps you can take to reduce the chances of a premium increase:
Maintain a Clean Driving Record
Even minor violations or at-fault accidents can impact your rates, so drive cautiously and obey traffic laws.Limit Claims
Consider paying for minor damages, windshield chip repairs, windshield replacements, or roadside services out of pocket to avoid filing claims for small expenses.Review Your Coverage Regularly
Work with an independent insurance agent, like 643 Insurance, to review your policy and explore discounts or coverage adjustments to offset potential premium increases.
Final Thoughts
While it may seem unfair that not-at-fault accidents, roadside assistance claims, or windshield replacements can lead to higher premiums, these adjustments are part of how insurers manage risk and maintain financial stability. At 643 Insurance, we’re here to help you navigate these complexities and find the coverage that fits your needs at the best possible rate.
If you have any questions about your premium or need help finding the right auto insurance policy, contact us today at 643 Insurance and let’s work together to keep you covered without breaking the bank!
Subscribe to our newsletter!